Elasticsearch search is being refreshed. Please retry in a moment.

CO129-190 - Governor Hennessy - 1880 [10-12] — Page 139

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

in Bankruptcy and in Probate jurisdiction should be heard in Chambers or in the large Court.

I had discretion decided to hear certain matters in each jurisdiction in Chambers, and I duly sat in Chambers from time to time for the purpose: but Mr Gibbons has day by day refused to attend in Chambers insisting that I had power to sit in the large Court only and in his place, and he has sat in the large Court repeatedly.

Mr Justice Suordear has by his exhaustive argument proved that from first to last my decision & actions were strictly according to practice, procedure, and Law, but that Mr Gibbons' conduct has been throughout irregular, contrary to practice, procedure and Law.

I submit that even if Mr Gibbons had been right in law, it was insubordination in him as an Officer subordinate to the Judge to set his opinion in public against mine, creating the public scandal which culminated in his utterances in open Court.

Edit History

2026-05-22 00:54:35 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
in Bankruptcy and in Probate jurisdiction should be heard in Chambers or in the large Court. I had discretion decided to hear certain matters in each jurisdiction in Chambers, and I duly sat in Chambers from time to time for the purpose: but Mr Gibbons has day by day refused to attend in Chambers insisting that I had power to sit in the large Court only and in his place, and he has sat in the large Court repeatedly. Mr Justice Suordear has by his exhaustive argument proved that from first to last my decision & actions were strictly according to practice, procedure, and Law, but that Mr Gibbons' conduct has been throughout irregular, contrary to practice, procedure and Law. I submit that even if Mr Gibbons had been right in law, it was insubordination in him as an Officer subordinate to the Judge to set his opinion in public against mine, creating the public scandal which culminated in his utterances in open Court.
Baseline (Original)
in Bankruptcy and in Probate furisdiction should be heard in or in the large Const. Chambers thad 12.7/ my discretion decided to hear certain matters in Each Jurisdiction in Chambers, and I I duly sat in Chambers from time to time for the purpose: but Mr Gibbons has day by day refused 1.212. to atterid in Chambers insisting that I had power these matters to sit viv these in the large Court only and in Climbers his place erot and he has sat in the large Court repeatedly 4-4*3A36, Rab!7," ! ! !F%ami*¢4" » H-i*-ཅ དཿp#f hp€ "i ! ༧‚1-བསaཡ 137 Coust in the presence of a reportes he ascertained. which A 02.1 Saturday last of full report appeared China mark of that evening. 2 d d the Mr Justice Suordear has by his exhaustive argument proved that from first to last were my decision & actione strictly according to prachos, procedure, and Law, but that m' Gibbons conduct has been throughout irregular, Contrary to practise, procedure and Law. I submit that even if McGibbons had been right in law, it in him as ai was insubor. dination Officer subordinate to the sending t my Chambers with inquiries Judges to set exp his opinion in publie whether I was Conving inte Coust thus creating the public scandal which culminated in his ritterances and to act in public contrary to the decision of the Judge, open Const haverer wrong that Dec. (6 rms.1
2026-05-22 00:54:35 · Baseline
View content

in Bankruptcy and in Probate furisdiction should be heard in

or in the large Const.

Chambers

thad

12.7/

my

discretion decided

to hear certain matters in Each

Jurisdiction in Chambers, and

I

I duly

sat in Chambers from time to time for the purpose: but Mr Gibbons

has day by day refused

1.212.

to

atterid

in Chambers insisting that

I had power

these matters

to sit

viv these

in the large Court only and

in

Climbers

his place

erot

and he has sat in

the large Court repeatedly

4-4*3A36, Rab!7," ! ! !F%ami*¢4" » H-i*-ཅ དཿp#f hp€ "i ! ༧‚1-བསaཡ

137

Coust in the presence of a reportes

he ascertained.

which

A

02.1

Saturday last of

full report appeared

China mark of that evening.

2

d d

the

Mr Justice Suordear has by his exhaustive argument proved that from

first to last

were

my

decision & actione

strictly according to prachos, procedure, and Law, but that m' Gibbons conduct has been throughout irregular, Contrary to practise, procedure and Law.

I submit that even if McGibbons

had been right in law, it

in him as ai

was insubor.

dination

Officer subordinate to the

sending t

my

Chambers with inquiries

Judges to set

exp

his opinion in publie

whether I was

Conving

inte Coust thus

creating the public scandal which

culminated in his ritterances

and to act in public contrary to the decision of the Judge,

open

Const

haverer

wrong

that

Dec.

(6 rms.1

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.